When you purchase through links on our site , we may realize an affiliate commission . Here ’s how it figure out .
For more than a millennium , scholar have find a rummy correlational statistics : atheist incline to be more intelligent than spiritual multitude .
It ’s unclear why this tendency prevail , but researchers of a newfangled study have an idea : Religion is an instinct , they say , and people who can rise above instinct are more levelheaded than those who rely on them .
" Intelligence — in rationally lick problem — can be understood as involve overcoming instinct and being intellectually curious and thus receptive to non - natural possibilities , " study confidential information author Edward Dutton , a enquiry fellow at the Ulster Institute for Social Research in the United Kingdom , say in a program line . [ Saint or Spiritual Slacker ? Test Your Religious Knowledge ]
Smart cookie
In classic Greece and Rome , it was widely remarked that " fool " tended to be religious , while the " wise " were often doubter , Dutton and his co - generator , Dimitri Van der Linden , an assistant prof of psychology at Erasmus University Rotterdam in the Netherlands , wrote in the subject field .
The ancient were n’t the only one to notice this tie-up . scientist ran a meta - analytic thinking of 63 studies and determine that religious people be given to be less intelligent than nonreligious people . The association was stronger among college student and the cosmopolitan world than for those young than college age , they find . The association was also stronger for religious beliefs , rather than religious behavior , allot to the meta - analysis , published in 2013 in thejournal Personality and Social Psychology Review .
But why does this association be ? Dutton set out to find answer , thinking that perhaps it was because nonreligious the great unwashed were more rational than their spiritual buddy , and thus better able-bodied to reason that there was no God , he spell .
But " more recently , I start up to inquire if I ’d got it awry , actually , " Dutton told Live Science . " I found evidence that intelligence is positively associated with sealed sort of bias . "
For instance , a 2012 study publish in theJournal of Personality and Social Psychologyshowed that college students often get logical answers wrong but do n’t recognise it . This so - call " prejudice unsighted spot " happens when people can not detect bias , or flaw , within their own thinking . " If anything , a larger bias unreasoning spot was associated with higher cognitive power , " the researchers of the 2012 study compose in the abstract .
One question , for example , asked the scholar : " A bat and a ball cost $ 1.10 in total . The bat cost $ 1.00 more than the ballock . How much does the ball cost ? " The job is n’t intuitive ( the answer is not 10 cents ) , but rather require scholar tosuppress or evaluatethe first solution that outflow into their mind , the researcher wrote in the discipline . If they do this , they might happen the right response : The glob cost 5 cents , and the bat costs $ 1.05 .
If intelligent people are less likely to comprehend their own prejudice , that means they ’re less rational in some respect , Dutton said . So why is intelligence associated with godlessness ? The response , he and his colleague suggest , is that religion is an instinct , and it guide news to overtake an inherent aptitude , Dutton said . [ 8 Ways Religion affect Your Life ]
Basic instinct
The faith - is - an - instinct possibility is a modify reading of an theme developed by Satoshi Kanazawa , an evolutionary psychologist at the London School of Economics , who was not involve in the new study .
Called the Savanna - IQ Interaction Hypothesis , Kanazawa ’s possibility undertake to explain the difference in the doings and attitude between intelligent and less healthy mass , enjoin Nathan Cofnas , who is pursue a doctor’s degree in philosophy at the University of Oxford in the United Kingdom this fall . Cofnas , who specialise in the school of thought of scientific discipline , was not involved with the new sketch .
The hypothesis is based on two premise , Cofnas told Live Science in an email .
" First , that we are psychologically adapted to solve recurrentproblems face by our Orion - accumulator ancestorsin the African savannah , " Cofnas said . " Second , that ' general intelligence activity ' ( what is measured by IQ tests ) evolve to help oneself us make out withnonrecurrentproblems for which we had no evolved psychological adaptations . "
The assumptions imply that " intelligent people should be better than unintelligent citizenry at dealing with ' evolutionary novelty ' — position and entity that did not exist in the patrimonial environment , " Cofnas said .
Dutton and Van der Linden qualify this theory , intimate that evolutionary novelty is something that pit evolved instinct .
Philosophical take
The approach is an interesting one , but might have firmer stand if the researchers explained exactly what they intend by " spiritual inherent aptitude , " Cofnas enounce .
" Dutton and Van der Linden pop the question that , if religion has an instinctual cornerstone , intelligent masses will be better able to master it and take up godlessness , " Cofnas say . " But without hump the exact nature of the ' spiritual inherent aptitude , ' we ca n’t rule out the possibility that godlessness , or at least some forms of atheism , rein in the same instinct(s ) . "
For case , writer Christopher Hitchens thought that communism was a religious belief ; temporal bowel movement , such as veganism , invoke to many of the same impulses — and peradventure ' instincts ' — that traditional religions do , Cofnas articulate . spiritual and nonreligious movement both rely on trust , identify witha community of believersand zealotry , he said .
" I recollect it ’s deceptive to use the full term ' religion ' as a slur for whatever you do n’t wish , " Cofnas enunciate .
Religion and stress
The research worker also examine the link between instinct and emphasis , emphasizing that masses run to work on instinct during nerve-racking times , for instance , turn to religion duringa near - death experience .
The researchers debate that intelligence serve citizenry surface above these instinct during times of tension . [ 11 Tips to depress Stress ]
" If faith is indeed an evolved domain — an instinct — then it will become heightened at times of emphasis , when hoi polloi are inclined to act instinctively , and there is clear evidence for this , " Dutton said . " It also entail that intelligence operation allow us to be able to pause and reason through the situation and the possible consequence of our actions . "
People who are able to go up above their instincts are likely better problem - problem solver , Dutton remark .
" Let ’s say someone had a go at you . Your inherent aptitude would be to punch them in the face , " Dutton told Live Science . " A more intelligent person will be able to stop themselves from doing that , reason it through and better lick the problem , according to what they need . "
The study was bring out May 16 in thejournal Evolutionary Psychological Science .
Original clause onLive Science .
